A friend emailed me on Friday telling me to go see the movie
Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed which had just opened. It sounded interesting so I made a plan to go and see it during the "city day" that honeypot and I had planned and it worked out well because the only theater this
movie was playing in the Bay Area was in SF.
We saw the movie and I fell asleep during part of it. That's not to say the content wasn't interesting, and it did actually bring up a couple really good points. Before I continue with the details of the movie, let me ask you a couple questions. First, do you believe in
Darwin's theory of evolution? (I do.) Second, do you believe in
intelligent design?
The main point of the movie is to show how highly respected scientists who firmly believe in evolution, but merely mention intelligent design are being ostracized by their scientific communities, as if they had stated their belief in
creationism. Why is this so ridiculous, well let me explain:
Darwin's theory of evolution begins after the first cell exists on Earth. The theory of evolution is the process of change in the inherited traits of a population of organisms from one generation to the next. This is how a single cell organism evolved to be you!
The theory of evolution does not deal with how that first cell got there in the first place. Intelligent design is one theory to answer that question. Intelligent design is the idea that something specifically put that first cell on Earth. That could be some smarter (or dumber depending on how you look at the human race on earth currently) life form from another place who used Earth as a big petri dish to see what would happen, or that could be some higher power like God (I know, it's the scary G word), or some other source that doesn't involve randomness.
The prevailing Darwinian scientist's theory as to where that first cell came from are something along the lines of this: somehow some crystal formations caused the first cell to come into existence, or the mud puddle theory (right place, right substances, right conditions created that first cell.) Um, ..crystals, .. or .. um.. mud puddle .. hmmm... There aren't many good origination options here.
Do you see how being an evolutionist and an intelligent design supporter aren't exclusive to each other? You can be both, and I think I am actually both. I really like the alien idea and earth being a big petri dish and of course I believe we evolved from apes.
So the movie demonstrates that there's this ridiculous backlash against anybody that whispers the words intelligent design in a scientific setting. And it's pretty fierce, and not very scientific of people, to shut out this one theory, especially when the "prevailing" origination theories are pretty far fetched, in my opinion.
I'd like to take this moment to point out that creationism is the idea that God created us in our likeness right now. In the theory of creationism, humans didn't evolve from gorillas; this is exactly how God made us. This has no relationship to the movie or intelligent design, but I think many people get Intelligent Design and Creationism confused. They are not really related except that intelligent design and creationism might agree that God created that first cell. That's where the similarities end.
So, to all my scientist friends out there that might want to keep working in science - I would convince yourself that you believe in the crystal formation, or mud pie theory for the origination of that first cell, never mention intelligent design, and you'll be safely employed for the rest of your days. (Or you could buck the system - and come and stay with me in our guest room.)
The movie is worth watching. It's not as amazingly eye opening as some other movies designed to shed light on some issues, but it's well researched and demonstrates how unscientific the scientific community is about this one theory of where that first cell came from.
Thanks Steve! See you at your wedding (w/ my honeypot!)